theGrio

Main menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Living
    • Health
  • Inspiration
    • Good News
  • Entertainment
    • Music
    • The Dish
  • News
    • Education
    • Sports
    • Black History

Red, Black & Blue

  • thanksgiving-travel-16x9.jpg

    Holiday safety tips

  • Meagan Good

    Good staying celibate

  • obama-and-choom-gang-16x9

    Obama's pot history

  • 2) I Am Legend (2007): In arguably one of his greatest dramatic performances, Smith held the screen virtually all by himself for most of this apocalyptic thriller's running time. He plays a military scientist who may or may not be the last man on the planet.  A scary good time at the movies.

    Will Smith's top 10 films

Kagan unscathed after revelations from past

by theGrio | June 21, 2010 at 1:42 PM
Comments
Print

WASHINGTON (AP) — Tens of thousands of pages worth of documents from Elena Kagan’s past have left President Barack Obama’s Supreme Court nominee relatively unscathed and important details about her still a mystery heading into confirmation hearings for a lifetime job as a justice.

Documents from Kagan’s service in the Clinton White House, including her own e-mails as a policy aide and lawyer, reinforce the portrait that’s emerged in recent weeks: a politically savvy, sometimes hard-edged strategist whose views of the Constitution are at odds with those of conservatives.

In a 1997 e-mail about former Justice Thurgood Marshall, Kagan wrote admiringly of her legal mentor’s view of the Constitution as a “living charter” and his concern as a justice for “the underdog.”

It’s not surprising language coming from a Democratic president’s nominee. It’s also probably going to underscore the Republicans’ line of argument that she will be a liberal activist from the bench.

WATCH ‘COUNTDOWN’ COVERAGE OF KAGAN:

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

From the records, there is scant evidence about what kind of justice Kagan would be.

Supporters suggest she can serve as a consensus-builder among deeply divided conservatives and liberals on the nine-member court.

In addition, newly released records from the Defense Department that detail her dispute with the Pentagon on military recruiters’ access to the campus of Harvard Law School, where she was dean, appear to contain little ammunition for GOP critics.

These documents show that long before Kagan decided to bar recruiters from the campus career services office because of the military’s policy against openly gay soldiers, at least one Pentagon official said the approach gave recruiters access that matched that of other prospective employers at the law school.

“Thank you for providing our military recruiters a degree of access to students that is equal in quality and scope to that afforded to other employers,” an Army judge advocate recruiter wrote in 1998 to Kagan’s predecessor, who set the policy she would later use.

The Obama White House has worked to ensure that no revelation from the documents harms Kagan’s chances. Working with former President Bill Clinton, officials shielded from public view most details about Kagan’s work on the scandals that in many ways defined his tenure. That includes her role defending him from the Paula Jones sexual harassment lawsuit that led to his impeachment.

In all, nearly 160,000 pages were unearthed, including 80,000 pages of e-mail — an unprecedented release for a Supreme Court nominee. They were dribbled out on Friday afternoons, the customary time in official Washington for releasing unfavorable information or material one hopes attracts little notice. The e-mails emerged late Friday afternoon; the Pentagon documents on Saturday.

Conservative activists say that’s no accident.

The Clinton-era documents portray Kagan as a “political operative … with disdain for the Second Amendment and the NRA (National Rifle Association), concern for currying favor with gay and lesbian groups, and support for judges who will decide cases by giving an edge to ‘the underdog’ and interpreting the Constitution as a ‘living,’ malleable document,” said Carrie Severino of the Judicial Crisis Network.

The timing, she added, “represents the Obama administration’s best political maneuver to hide any information revealed about the president’s Supreme Court nominee in the Saturday papers.”

But the revelations are fairly thin.

The files say more about Kagan as a person and political operator than about what kind of jurisprudence she might practice. She comes across as a sharp intellect and somewhat territorial; highly opinionated but eager to facilitate consensus; with little tolerance for lofty rhetoric and a playful, dry wit.

In a 1997 e-mail to her boss at Clinton’s Domestic Policy Council, Kagan seemed to acknowledge her willingness to throw elbows in a White House full of overachievers. “I’ll be as insistent as I know how to be (which, as you know, … ),” she wrote Bruce Reed.

To a colleague passing along request from the Women’s Office to see a copy of a directive she was drafting, Kagan responded simply but emphatically: “NOOOOOO.”

Kagan wasn’t afraid to challenge leading members of the administration when she felt strongly about something or her political instincts told her they were doing the wrong things.

In a 1999 e-mail, she called herself one of the Clinton White House’s biggest fans of a law to protect religious freedom, but warned then-Vice President Al Gore against endorsing it for fear of creating “a gay/lesbian firestorm.” She told his chief of staff, Ron Klain — who now holds the same job for Vice President Joe Biden — that aides were meeting with religious and gay groups to try to smooth over their differences on the matter.

“We’ll let you know as soon as it’s safe to go back in the water,” she wrote.

The previous year, she counseled against having Hillary Rodham Clinton announce new policies or promises in a speech about race.

“I’m generally not in favor of the FLOTUS announcing policy unless it’s in one of her areas (e.g., child care),” Kagan responded, using the White House shorthand for first lady of the United States. “I’d go for a promising practice instead.”

But Kagan was more than willing to reach for more responsibility in Clinton’s White House, particularly in policy areas she was passionate about. Affirmative action and campaign finance were two, according to a 1995 e-mail.

In a note to Abner Mikva, a White House counsel under Clinton, Kagan lobbied to be put in charge of affirmative action, given that presidential race adviser Chris Edley was leaving.

“Is there a need for someone to keep on top of the affirmative action issue — for example, by working with Justice on its review of all affirmative action programs? I know the issue well (because I teach it) and care about it a lot; if there’s stuff to do here, I’d love to do it.”

Copyright 2010 The Associated Press.

Filed in: News, Politics, Top Stories, Video | Related Topics: Elena Kagan, Justice Thurgood Marshall, President Obama, Supeme Court
  • Top Stories in Politics

    • Obama’s pot history Obama’s pot history
    • Obama struggles with low-income whites Obama struggles with low-income whites
    • Woman claims she dressed like Obama for Berlusconi Woman claims she dressed like Obama for Berlusconi
    • Romney hires veteran black strategist Romney hires veteran black strategist
    • Obama honors veterans during Memorial Day weekend
    • Obama photo remains in West Wing
    • Florida voters support ‘Stand Your Ground’ law
    • Booker: ‘My loyalties are clear’
  • New Stories on theGrio

    • How Harry Truman desegregated the military How Harry Truman desegregated the military
    • How WWII vets helped lead the civil rights fight How WWII vets helped lead the civil rights fight
    • Rangel on black America’s truest heroes Rangel on black America’s truest heroes
    • Remembering America’s black war heroes Remembering America’s black war heroes
    • Beyoncé performs for first lady, Malia and Sasha
    • Rape conviction overturned: Now what?
    • Rap Genius: Top 5 rap lyrics of the week
    • Hidden WWII film could aid today’s vets
  • LIKE TheGrio

  • Hot on Facebook

  • Category Cloud

    Atlanta Black History Business Chicago Detroit Education Entertainment Health Inspiration Living Los Angeles Miami Money News New York Opinion Philadelphia Politics Reviews Service and Activism Slideshow Sports TheGrio's 100 TheGrio's 100 Women Top Stories Travel and Leisure Video Washington DC
  • More from theGrio

More Stories on theGrio

Top News

Politics

  • In this Jan. 23, 1942 black-and-white file photo, Major James A. Ellison, left, returns the salute of Mac Ross of Dayton, Ohio, as he inspects the cadets at the Basic and Advanced Flying School for Negro Air Corps Cadets at the Tuskegee Institute in Tuskegee, Ala. Sixty years after President Truman desegregated the military, senior black officers are still rare, particularly among the highest ranks. (AP Photo/U.S. Army Signal Corps, File)

    Rangel on black America's truest heroes

  • Obama honors veterans during Memorial Day weekend

  • Woman claims she dressed like Obama for Berlusconi

  • Florida voters support 'Stand Your Ground' law

» Read More in Politics

Business

  • © olly - Fotolia.com

    Black Enterprise celebrates largest black companies

  • Facebook unveils Instagram rival

  • Donna Summer album sales up 3,277 percent

  • 5 resources for black entrepreneurs

» Read More in Business

Living

  • thanksgiving-travel-16x9.jpg

    Holiday safety tips

  • Good staying celibate

  • School to distribute condoms at prom

  • 'He tucks me in,' first lady says of president

» Read More in Living

Inspiration

  • 20120528-003600.jpg

    How Harry Truman desegregated the military

  • How WWII vets helped lead the civil rights fight

  • Remembering America's black war heroes

  • Tuskegee Airman grants b'day wish

» Read More in Inspiration

Entertainment

  • In this Friday May 25, 2012 photo provided by Parkwood Entertainment, Beyonce performs at Revel in Atlantic City, N.J., for the resort's premiere. (AP Photo/Parkwood Entertainment, Robin Harper)

    Beyoncé performs for first lady, Malia and Sasha

  • Rap Genius: Top 5 rap lyrics of the week

  • 50 Cent endorses marrige equality

  • Meet the breakout star of 'Battleship'

» Read More in Entertainment

News

  • This May 24, 2012 file photo shows Brian Banks reacting in court after his rape conviction was dismissed in Long Beach, Calif. (AP Photo/Nick Ut)

    Rape conviction overturned: Now what?

  • Hidden WWII film could aid today's vets

  • Kyrie Irving poses as 'Uncle Drew' in new Pepsi ad

  • Backlash against African migrants in Israel

» Read More in News

Main menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Living
  • Inspiration
  • Entertainment
  • News
  • Help
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise with TheGrio
  • About
©2010 NBCUniversal
Powered by WordPress.com VIP