theGrio

Back to the Top

Main menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
  • Home
  • Entertainment
    • Music
    • The Dish
  • Health
    • Ask Dr. Ty
    • Black Men’s Health
    • Black Women and Breast Cancer
    • Back to School Health
  • Living
    • Travel and Leisure
    • Living Forward
    • Books
  • Politics
    • Perry on Politics
  • Sports
  • News
    • Good News
  • Opinion

Red, Black & Blue

Clarence Thomas: The elephant in the room on health care reform

by David A. Love | November 15, 2011 at 8:10 AM
Comments
Print

Related Posts

  • Will Clarence and Virginia Thomas kill Obama's health care plan?
  • Can the Supreme Court sabotage Obama's health reform?
  • Liberal advocacy groups get 100k signatures for Justice Clarance Thomas to 'recuse' himself
  • Did Clarence Thomas leak story alleging Roberts Supreme Court health care switch?
  • Clarence Thomas, Elena Kagan and the battle over who gets to rule

The U.S. Supreme Court has decided to hear arguments next March on the constitutionality of President Barack Obama’s health care law; the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, known derisively by some of his conservative critics as “Obamacare.”

The high court will determine the constitutionality of a key provision of the law, mandating that people buy health insurance beginning in 2014 or pay a tax penalty. And the justices will also decide whether the rest of the health care law is valid if the so-called “individual mandate” is invalidated.

theGRIO OPINION: Is Clarence Thomas unfit to serve on the Supreme Court?

Other issues for the court to review include the law’s expansion of Medicare — which requires states to offer coverage to anyone earning less than 133 percent of the federal poverty limit, or lose funding — and the question of whether the courts lack jurisdiction to decide the case because it is premature.

Many provisions of the health care overhaul have not yet taken effect.

WATCH NBC NIGHTLY NEWS COVERAGE OF OBAMA’S HEALTH CARE FIGHT:

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Federal appeals courts in Washington D.C. and Cincinnati recently upheld the law, while an appellate court in Atlanta ruled that Congress exceeded its powers when it enacted the mandate.

With a Supreme Court ruling likely to come down just months before Election Day, next November, this promises to be a politically charged case. The Obama administration and Republicans alike have already predicted a victory for their side.

One question that remains is whether some of the justices, including Clarence Thomas, will recuse themselves due to a perceived conflict of interest. After all,the deck — or rather the court — may already be stacked against the law.

Oddly, the very same day the court decided to take the case, Justices Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas attended a dinner in their honor. Among the sponsors of that dinner was Bancroft PLLC, the law firm arguing the case before the court, and Pfizer Inc., which has a huge stake in the outcome of the case.

Moreover, Thomas in particular would appear to have a glaring conflict of interest in the form of his wife, Virginia, also known as Ginni. The judge was slow to disclose that Ginni earned lots of money as a leader in the Tea Party movement, among the most vocal opponents of the president’s health care reform.

As president and CEO of the Tea Party group Liberty Central, Mrs. Thomas earned $150,000, as well as nearly $15,000 from her anti-health care lobbying firm. Ultimately, she was forced to step down from Liberty Central, where she fought to bring down the health care law.

According to Justice Thomas, he claimed he failed to file the information on his wife’s employment “due to a misunderstanding of the filing instructions.”

Justices Thomas and Scalia also attended events sponsored by Koch Industries, the billionaire philanthropists for the anti-Obama Tea Party. Specifically, they dined and were featured speakers at Koch-sponsored events, and attended Koch financed political retreats.

And the Koch brothers were the primary beneficiaries of the court’s Citizens United decision, from which Scalia and Thomas did not recuse themselves. That decision allowed for the unlimited corrupting influence of money in political campaigns.

Meanwhile, conservatives have called on Justice Elena Kagan to recuse herself from the case due to her role in giving advice and strategizing on the law while serving as Solicitor General from March 2009 until her confirmation to the high court in August 2010.

There is no indication that Kagan or Thomas intend to bow out of the decision.

Justices are expected to recuse themselves from a case if they have a conflict of interest or their spouses have a financial interest. In the end, whether or not to recuse is up to the individual judge.

All of this is designed to maintain the integrity of the courts. At a time when so many people have lost faith in government, in Washington politics, and in the justice system, it is important for our leaders to avoid even the perception that they are for sale; that the fix is in.

Can Clarence Thomas review the health care case fairly and impartially, even though he broke bread with the Tea Party’s bankrollers, and his wife lobbied against the law and was paid handily for it? Maybe, maybe not. But if this case further pushes the U.S.Supreme Court towards kangaroo court status, not unlike Bush v. Gore, the case that decided the disputed 2000 presidential election, and the Citizens United case, in which corporations were given wide latitude to fund American elections, it will have Thomas’s fingerprints all over it.

  • gloria-cain-fox-news-interview.jpg
    Next Story:

    Gloria Cain stands by her man, but is it too little, too late?

  • herman-cain-oops-on-libya.jpg
    Previous Story:

    Cain stumbles talking about intervention in Libya

Filed in: Politics, Top Stories, Video | Related Topics: Barack Obama, Clarence Thomas, Health Care Reform, Obamacare, Supreme Court, Virginia Thomas
  • Learn about our User Panel

    Read More
  • New Stories on theGrio

    • Goodie Mob together again Goodie Mob together again
    • Mariah Carey and Nicki Minaj reuniting? Mariah Carey and Nicki Minaj reuniting?
    • Frederick Douglass statue unveiled Frederick Douglass statue unveiled
    • Living with Sickle Cell: An inspirational journey Living with Sickle Cell: An inspirational journey
    • HPV vaccine cut infection by half in teens
    • Real-life ‘Snakes on a Plane’ incident
    • Obama renews calls for nuclear reductions
    • Serena’s Steubenville controversy
  • What Your Friends Are Reading

  • More from theGrio

More Stories on theGrio

Top News

Politics

  • Jesse Jackson Jr. (Photo courtesy of NBC Chicago)

    Jesse Jackson Jr. wants to serve prison time before wife

  • First lady inspires youth of Ireland

  • Obama rejects Bush comparisons

  • White House threatens veto of bill with food stamps cuts

» Read More in Politics

Business

  • This May 1, 2013 file photo shows Jay-Z at "The Great Gatsby" world premiere at Avery Fisher Hall in New York.  (Photo by Evan Agostini/Invision/AP, file )

    With Samsung, business is booming for Jay-Z

  • Jay-Z announces new album

  • Dunkin' Donuts: Workers who endured racist rant will be 'honored'

  • Greene Scholars seeks to place black youth in STEM jobs

» Read More in Business

Living

  • People come out of their homes to a flooded street after Hurricane Katrina hit the area with heavy wind and rain August 29, 2005 in New Orleans, Louisiana. Katrina was down graded to a category 4 storm as it approached New Orleans. (Photo by Mark Wilson/Getty Images)

    Climate change vs. black America

  • Serena Williams works teeny bikini on Miami Beach

  • Daughter inspires mom's natural hair care company

  • Dad to son: A secret to get ahead

» Read More in Living

Inspiration

  • Ethel “Ellie” Hylton

    Woman graduates with highest GPA at Harvard

  • Ne-Yo: Fatherhood 'means being there'

  • Adele honored by Queen Elizabeth II

  • Man finds father through Facebook

» Read More in Inspiration

Entertainment

  • Vin Diesel as Riddick in 'Riddick: Rule The Dark'. (Photo courtesy Universal.)

    Vin Diesel talks new 'Riddick' film

  • 'Dark Girls' set to debut on OWN

  • Scott Disick plays 'American Psycho' for Kanye

  • Cosby pays tribute to his late son

» Read More in Entertainment

News

  • George Zimmerman talks to his attorney Mark O'Mara, right, during a recess in Seminole circuit court during Zimmerman's trial in Sanford, Fla., Monday, June 17, 2013. Zimmerman has been charged with second-degree murder for the 2012 shooting death of Trayvon Martin. He has plead not guilty to the charges. (AP Photo/Orlando Sentinel, Joe Burbank, Pool)

    911 call debated at Zimmerman trial

  • Mom seeks help to find son's killer

  • Chicago teen fatally shot by cops

  • Officers allegedly sell inmates drugs

» Read More in News

Main menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
  • Politics
  • Living
  • Video
  • Inspire
  • Health
  • Entertainment
  • News
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise with TheGrio
  • About
©2013 NBCUniversal
Powered by WordPress.com VIP