theGrio

Back to the Top

Main menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
  • Home
  • Entertainment
    • Music
    • The Dish
  • Health
    • Ask Dr. Ty
    • Black Men’s Health
    • Black Women and Breast Cancer
    • Back to School Health
  • Living
    • Travel and Leisure
    • Living Forward
    • Books
  • Politics
    • Perry on Politics
  • Sports
  • News
    • Good News
  • Opinion

News

Trial in 1977 killing asks: Were suspects framed?

by Ryan J. Foley, Associated Press | October 30, 2012 at 1:35 PM
Comments
Print
In this April 16, 2003 file photo, Terry Harrington, center, stands with his daughter Nicole Brown, left, his mother Josephine James, right, and family and friends outside the Clarinda Correctional Facility in Clarinda, Iowa, after Gov. Tom Vilsack signed his reprieve. Harrington and Curtis McGhee, wrongfully convicted in the 1977 murder of a retired Iowa police officer, hope to prove during a trial that starts Wednesday, Oct. 31, 2012, that officers coerced witnesses into fabricating testimony that framed them for killing John Schweer. (AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall, File)

In this April 16, 2003 file photo, Terry Harrington, center, stands with his daughter Nicole Brown, left, his mother Josephine James, right, and family and friends outside the Clarinda Correctional Facility in Clarinda, Iowa, after Gov. Tom Vilsack signed his reprieve. Harrington and Curtis McGhee, wrongfully convicted in the 1977 murder of a retired Iowa police officer, hope to prove during a trial that starts Wednesday, Oct. 31, 2012, that officers coerced witnesses into fabricating testimony that framed them for killing John Schweer. (AP Photo/Charlie Neibergall, File)

Related Posts

  • Witness: Iowa player grabbed condoms before assault
  • Ex-Iowa football player convicted of assault
  • Iowa felons disenfranchised in pursuit of voting rights
  • Flavor Flav's fried chicken restaurant closes in Iowa
  • Oprah meditates with women during Iowa visit

IOWA CITY, Iowa (AP) — Two black men wrongly convicted in the 1977 murder of a white Iowa police officer hope to prove something they couldn’t during trials that sent them to prison for 25 years: that detectives framed them to solve a high-profile case.

During a civil trial that starts Wednesday in Des Moines, Terry Harrington and Curtis McGhee will argue that Council Bluffs police officers coerced witnesses into fabricating testimony against them in the killing of John Schweer.

Schweer was found dead while working as the night watchman at a car dealership. Harrington and McGhee, then teenagers from neighboring Omaha, Neb., say detectives used threats against a group of young black car theft suspects to trump up evidence targeting them because of their race and pressure to solve the retired captain’s killing.

Despite little physical evidence, Harrington and McGhee were convicted at 1978 trials and sentenced to long prison terms. They were freed in 2003, after the Iowa Supreme Court found that prosecutors committed misconduct in concealing reports about another man seen near the crime scene with a shotgun. The key witnesses had also recanted their testimony, saying they were pressured into implicating the men.

After winning their freedom, they filed lawsuits against prosecutors and officers they blamed for forcing them to spend their adult lives in the Fort Madison prison. Their case reached the U.S. Supreme Court in 2009 over the issue of whether suspects have the constitutional right not to be framed by prosecutors. Before justices ruled, Pottawatamie County agreed to pay $12 million to settle claims against two former prosecutors while not admitting wrongdoing.

The settlement did not resolve claims against Council Bluffs and former detectives Dan Larsen and Lyle Brown.

Harrington and McGhee claim Larsen and Brown coerced the group of black car theft suspects into fingering them in the death. Investigators took the star witness, a 16-year-old confessed liar with numerous aliases, to the crime scene, gave him details about the murder weapon, and had him repeatedly change his story until it was plausible, the lawsuit claims.

The witness, Kevin Hughes, was aggressively questioned in Schweer’s death after he was pulled over several weeks later driving a vehicle stolen from a Nebraska dealership. He first implicated three other men who had alibis before eventually claiming Harrington pulled the trigger and McGhee drove the getaway car after they went to steal a car from the dealership Schweer was guarding. Hughes said later he lied to get reward money and avoid being charged himself. Other witnesses also recanted.

Jurors will be asked to decide at trial, scheduled to last through Nov. 16, whether detectives, who were both white, and the city violated Harrington and McGhee’s civil rights and, if so, how much they should receive in damages.

“We have waited for a very long time to have this trial and we look forward to having an opportunity to present our case,” said Stephen Davis, an attorney for McGhee, now married and living in a Midwestern community he does not want to disclosure.

Facing a possible verdict of millions, lawyers for the detectives and the city are making an aggressive defense. They plan to argue that Harrington and McGhee probably were the real killers — and that even if they weren’t, detectives did nothing wrong in focusing on them as suspects under the circumstances.

“There is going to be evidence that this civil jury will hear surrounding Terry Harrington and Curtis McGhee’s involvement in this crime and it’s evidence that the juries in 1978 considered,” said attorney Kristopher Madsen. “But importantly, we believe there’s going to be lacking any credible evidence to indicate these two police detectives in any way fabricated evidence or coerced or threatened witnesses or violated any civil rights of Harrington and McGhee.”

The stakes are high for the city because recent court rulings have concluded it will have little insurance coverage if liable.

Lawyers would not say how much compensation Harrington and McGhee would seek, but they plan to show jurors a mock prison cell to illustrate their lives behind bars. Harrington’s daughter, born after he was imprisoned, is expected to testify about the former high school football player’s long dream of freedom.

A key question will be why detectives stopped pursuing suspect Charles Gates. Police reports about Gates had been hidden from the defense and were uncovered in 1999 by a former prison barber who became convinced of Harrington’s innocence and worked for years for his freedom.

They showed that witnesses reported seeing a man with a dog carrying a shotgun near the crime scene, where Schweer’s bullet-riddled body was found surrounded by bloody dog prints. In the nights before his death, the police reports show Schweer reported having altercations with a white man carrying a shotgun and walking a dog — something Gates was known to do.

Police questioned Gates, a 48-year-old loner, and he failed a lie-detector test. He had also been a suspect in an earlier unsolved murder. Investigators even consulted an astrologer about Gates, but ignored him after Hughes and other teens were stopped in the stolen car. Gates denied in a 2003 interview with police that he was involved in the slaying. Attempts to find Gates and reach him for comment were not successful.

“Larsen and Brown thought it was their lucky day. They could pin the murder on them, or use them to pin it on some ‘ghetto dwellers’,” plaintiffs’ lawyers wrote, using a term detective Larsen once used to refer to Omaha residents. “Either way, Larsen and Brown would be putting blacks in front of a white Council Bluffs jury for the killing of a white Council Bluffs cop. That would mean case closed and they would be heroes.”

Copyright 2012 The Associated Press.

  • Wayne Simmonds (File Photo)
    Next Story:

    Racial slurs hurled at black hockey player in Czech Republic

  • (Photo: UF NAACP Facebook Page)
    Previous Story:

    University of Florida students’ blackface Halloween costumes draw criticism

Filed in: News | Related Topics: 1977, Curtis McGhee, Iowa, John Schweer, Justice, Murder, Terry Harrington, Wrongful Conviction
  • Learn about our User Panel

    Read More
  • New Stories on theGrio

    • ‘Britain’s Obama’ urges ties with Africa ‘Britain’s Obama’ urges ties with Africa
    • Are we deporting our democracy? Are we deporting our democracy?
    • Obama to Morehouse grads: Set an example Obama to Morehouse grads: Set an example
    • ‘Hero’ cop who sat beside first lady, facing rape charges ‘Hero’ cop who sat beside first lady, facing rape charges
    • WATCH: Kanye West performs on SNL
    • Full text: President Obama’s Morehouse speech
    • Black anti-abortion activists see ‘houses of horror’ everywhere
    • Malcolm X’s triumphs still trump his tragedies
  • What Your Friends Are Reading

  • More from theGrio

More Stories on theGrio

Top News

Politics

  • Non-profit groups often look for tax breaks

    Democratic, liberal groups got IRS scrutiny too

  • No, Obama is not Nixon

  • Eric Holder grilled by House committee

  • Where was the outrage over IRS' NAACP audit?

» Read More in Politics

Business

  • Eve

    A timeless classic: Top career lessons from ‘The Great Gatsby’

  • Boyz II Men appear in new Old Navy commercial

  • An open letter to PepsiCo on the Mountain Dew ad

  • Unemployment falls to 7.5 percent

» Read More in Business

Living

  • Natalie Clarice

    'Find Me My Man' star Natalie Clarice: Her tips for finding love

  • Zoe Saldana goes naked for Allure

  • 'Be My Slave' photo shoot causes controversy

  • Cory Booker raises thousands at UNCF Mayor's Masked Ball

» Read More in Living

Inspiration

  • Identical twins Kirstie and Kristie Bronner (Photo courtesy of Bronner family)

    Twins named Spelman valedictorians

  • DC Central Kitchen helps people struggling to join workforce

  • Man refuses to let disability hamper ability to teach

  • 'Supermom' dedicates her life to foster kids

» Read More in Inspiration

Entertainment

  • Kelly Rowland (Getty Images)

    Kelly Rowland: I was jealous of Beyoncé

  • Candice wins 'Idol'

  • Wade Robson: Michael Jackson abused me for 7 years

  • Basquiat painting fetches record $48.8M

» Read More in Entertainment

News

  • New Orleans suspect

    Second arrest in Mother's Day parade shooting

  • Pastor, Disney employee accused of watching child porn at work

  • Charges dropped in teen science experiment

  • Floyd Mayweather Jr. top-earning American athlete in 2013

» Read More in News

Main menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
  • Politics
  • Living
  • Video
  • Inspire
  • Health
  • Entertainment
  • News
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise with TheGrio
  • About
©2013 NBCUniversal
Powered by WordPress.com VIP