Black community torn over #BlackOutTuesday campaign

The hashtag has sparked criticism for its passive call-to-action and promotion of silence.

A smartphone displaying the Instagram #blackouttuesday account is seen in Washington on June 2, 2020. (Photo by ERIC BARADAT/AFP via Getty Images)

The Black community is in the midst of fighting for our right to live peacefully, but some of us are torn on the correct way to enact change.

This week, the music industry declared that they were going to “turn off the music” on Tuesday in an effort to reflect and inspire change amid nationwide protesting over the deaths of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, Ahmaud Arbery and other Black people who have been killed or terrorized.

“On Tuesday June 2nd, Columbia Records will observe ‘Black Out Tuesday,’” the Sony label, home to Beyoncé, Adele and John Legend, said in a statement. “This is not a day off. Instead, this is a day to reflect and figure out ways to move forward in solidarity.”

“We continue to stand with the Black community, our staff, artists, and peers in the music industry,” the company continued. “Perhaps with the music off, we can truly listen.”

The initiative soon transformed into #BlackOutTuesday, with thousands of people, from celebrities and activists to brands and companies, sharing a blacked out image on their social media channels in a show of solidarity.

However, some activists and community organizers argued that not only was the campaign ineffective, but it was actually harming the Black Lives Matter movement by flooding the hashtag #BlackLivesMatter with black squares, instead of resources, useful information or videos and photos of protesting.

Some public figures have found a happy medium, sharing the blacked out image alongside a call-to-action or resources that can tangibly help the movement. In the midst of the campaign, hundreds of people have continued to protest against police brutality through the streets of America’s major cities.

Instagram released a statement on Tuesday afternoon encouraging its users to continue to share, but with the correct hashtag. “We’re hearing asks from the community that posts related to Blackout Tuesday use the hashtag #blackouttuesday, and not #blacklivesmatter,” the company said. “The #blacklivesmatter hashtag aggregates important information and resources for the community.”