Statue to tennis star Arthur Ashe to stay put in Richmond after ‘White Lives Matter’ defacement

The Ashe family considered removing the statue temporarily after being defaced with "White Lives Matter"

Jul 12, 2020

Traffic passes by the statue of tennis star Arthur Ashe on Monument Avenue, Friday, July 10, 2020, in Richmond, Va. Family members of Ashe and city officials mulled moving the statue during the recent civil unrest. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)

RICHMOND, Va. (AP) — On Richmond’s Monument Avenue, the collection of towering statues honoring Confederate veterans was interrupted by one noticeably different: a monument to Black tennis legend and civil rights activist Arthur Ashe.

The Ashe statue seemed safe from defacement during recent protests over racism and police brutality, when protesters covered Confederate statues with graffiti and pulled down a statue of Jefferson Davis, the president of the Confederate States during the Civil War.

But after someone painted “White Lives Matter” on Ashe’s statue, city officials considered a request from Ashe’s family to temporarily remove the statue to protect it. Ashe’s nephew said Friday that the statue isn’t going anywhere.

“It’s not going to be taken down,” David Harris Jr. said.

This Jan. 10, 2019, file photo shows David Harris Jr., the nephew of Arthur Ashe, during an interview in Richmond, Va. (AP Photo/Steve Helber, File)

Harris said he contacted Mayor Levar Stoney’s office last month about taking down the statue until the civil unrest in Richmond calmed down.

Harris said the request was a “contingency plan” only during the height of the protests over the May 25 police killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis, when there were almost nightly clashes between police and protesters, and the Ashe family worried that the statue would be damaged or someone would try to topple it.

“We were just considering it at the height of the protesting so that if any credible threats came through Mayor Stoney had the leeway to do it without having any pushback from us if he felt the need to take it down,” Harris said.

Stoney’s spokesman, Jim Nolan, said Friday that the mayor is “going to listen to the family” and not remove the statue.

On July 1, Stoney ordered the immediate removal of all city-owned Confederate statues in Richmond, a onetime capital of the Confederacy. Stoney invoked his emergency powers, citing the ongoing civil unrest and concerns that protesters would get hurt if they tried to pull down the enormous statues themselves.

The statue of tennis star Arthur Ashe stands on Monument Avenue, Friday, July 10, 2020, in Richmond, Va. The city of Richmond removed 11 Confederate monuments along Monument Avenue as well as other locations in the city. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)

The only Confederate statue that remains on Monument Avenue is a memorial to Gen. Robert E. Lee located on state property. Gov. Ralph Northam ordered that statue’s removal last month, but it has been at least temporarily blocked by a lawsuit.

Harris said he believes his uncle’s statue “stands for everything the people are working for right now.”

Ashe, a Richmond native, was denied access to tennis courts as a child because of segregation. He went on to become the first Black player selected to the U.S. Davis Cup team and was the only Black man to ever win the singles title at the U.S. Open, Wimbledon and the Australian Open. He was also well-known for his work to promote education and civil rights, to oppose apartheid in South Africa and to raise awareness about AIDS, the disease that eventually killed him in 1993.

Ashe’s statue was erected in 1996, but only after rancorous debate.

“If we’re going to put up a statue of somebody, let’s put up a statue of somebody that stands for equality, that stands for education, all the things that my uncle held true,” Harris said.

Subscribe to theGrio’s Dear Culture podcast on Spotify, Apple and Stitcher.