Here’s your reminder that demonizing immigrants is actually anti-American

OPINION: Touré writes about the need for the United States to embrace undocumented immigrants -- not shun them.

immigration activist
An immigration activist participates in a rally near the U.S. Supreme Court as they demonstrate to highlight immigrant essential worker rights, on May 12, 2021 in Washington, DC.(Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)

Every few months, it seems there’s a new group of immigrants arriving from a different country, be it Haiti, Cuba, Afghanistan, Mexico or wherever. Immediately, they’re are demonized by right-wingers as if they’re coming to suck on America’s teet, grab up free stuff and generally ruin our country.

Watching the denigration of immigrants’ character is difficult, in part, because this issue is personal to me: My wife is a first-generation immigrant from Lebanon whose experience has given me a clearer view on what life can be like for immigrants.

No one packs a bag and flees their home country for a place where they know no one and don’t speak the language lightly. Thousands come to America because of a life emergency — oftentimes, there’s a war or widespread economic depravity in their home country. My wife was around 10 years of age when the fighting in the Lebanese Civil War came so close to her mother’s house that she was awakened by the sound of a bomb. She witnessed her mother, then a nurse, caring for injured, bloody people who came to her apartment in despair. Shortly after that, she and her mom left for America.

It’s crazy that so many people in the world see America as a great place to restart their lives, yet so many Americans see immigrants as an insidious blight on our day-to-day existence. Studies show that most immigrants come to America looking for work or to reunite with their families; most immigrants pay taxes and are less likely to engage in criminal behavior than Native American citizens, yet counterfactual myths about immigrants persist.

My wife and her mother had a tough time when they arrived in America, but they were never on welfare and they soon became tax-paying citizens and valuable members of their community.

I can’t imagine how heartless one must be to be to see someone whose life is in shambles and in desperate need of help, only to say, “Yeah, we can’t help you.” Or, “You don’t have the right paperwork.” Surely, a great and rich nation of 330 million can absorb a few thousand people. A look at the past several decades shows that immigrants from Cuba, Mexico and Southeast Asia have had a powerful and valuable impact on Miami, Texas and Southern California.

The notion that immigrants ruin America is consistently disproven; since being accepting of immigrants is a deeply-held American value, the demonization of immigrants is actually anti-American.

U.S. Border Patrol agents interact with Haitian immigrants, thegrio.com
U.S. Border Patrol agents interact with Haitian immigrants on the bank of the Rio Grande in Del Rio, Texas on September 20, 2021 as seen from Ciudad Acuna, Mexico. (Photo by John Moore/Getty Images)

You cannot, at once, claim that America is the world’s greatest nation and believe that it shouldn’t harbor those who need help. If we really are the greatest nation, that distinction comes with responsibilities, especially when many in need of our help can trace their troubles back to us: America’s attempts to spread democracy and our imperative to be the world’s policeman has, at times, led to the destabilization or the impoverishment of other nations.

It’s America’s long-term occupation of Middle Eastern nations that has fueled much of the fighting and political instability that ultimately led to my wife and mother-in-law needing to leave. It’s America’s long wars in Afghanistan and Vietnam that led to thousands of people from those nations needing to leave. It’s America’s policies toward Haiti and Cuba and Central America that have contributed to making life harder on the people of those nations, forcing them to leave.

We are, in many cases, complicit in immigrants’ need to flee their native countries. If we are not honest enough to admit this; if we are not big hearted enough to welcome the poor; if we are not rich enough to absorb new people who want to work; if we are not humane to people who are in need … are we really the world’s greatest nation?


Touré, theGrio.com

Touré is the host of the podcasts Toure Show and Democracyish and the podcast docuseries Who Was Prince? He is also the author of six books.

Have you subscribed to theGrio’s podcast “Dear Culture”? Download our newest episodes now!

TheGrio is now on Apple TV, Amazon Fire, and Roku. Download theGrio today!

Loading the player...