theGrio

Back to the Top

Main menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
  • Home
  • Entertainment
    • Music
    • The Dish
  • Health
    • Ask Dr. Ty
    • Black Men’s Health
    • Black Women and Breast Cancer
    • Back to School Health
  • Living
    • Travel and Leisure
    • Living Forward
    • Books
  • Politics
    • Perry on Politics
  • Sports
  • News
    • Good News
  • Opinion

Red, Black & Blue

Repealing Obama’s health care law won’t be easy

by Andrew Taylor, Associated Press | July 16, 2012 at 1:40 PM
Comments
Print
Gov. Mitt Romney, speaks about the Supreme Court's health care ruling in Washington. (AP Photo/Charles Dharapak, File)

Gov. Mitt Romney, speaks about the Supreme Court's health care ruling in Washington. (AP Photo/Charles Dharapak, File)

Related Posts

  • Allen West partially supports Obama's health care law
  • Obama's health care law advances in the states
  • Obama embraces drug prevention not punishment
  • Senate Republicans forcing a vote on health law
  • Obama confident health care law will be upheld

WASHINGTON (AP) — Yes, if Mitt Romney wins the White House and his Republican allies retake the Senate, he could shred most of President Barack Obama’s health care law without having to overpower a Democratic filibuster.

But it won’t be as easy as some Republicans portend, and it certainly won’t be quick.

Why?

Because any realistic effort to repeal the Affordable Care Act — as opposed to last week’s quixotic vote in the GOP-controlled House — is sure to get jumbled together with lots of other issues, including Medicare, taxes, food stamps and defense spending.

And that’s because Republicans have to first pass a budget. It’s the only way than can invoke special Senate rules that allow legislation to pass with just a simple majority vote — instead of the 60 votes needed in the 100-member Senate to beat a filibuster.

Passing a budget requires answering a raft of questions unrelated to the relatively simple idea of repealing “Obamacare.” How much to cut the deficit? Should Medicare be overhauled and Medicaid bear sharp cuts? Is it realistic to sharply boost defense programs, as Romney would like, in such an atmosphere?

The first step is to pass a budget resolution — a nonbinding, broad-brush outline of budget goals like cutting or increasing taxes, or slowing increases in Medicare. A budget resolution sets the terms for follow-up legislation that’s called a reconciliation bill in Washington argot.

Two years ago, Democrats used a reconciliation bill to finalize the health care law with a 56-43, party-line vote in the Senate.

Republicans have a problem in that there’s a lot more on their agenda than just repealing the health care law, and it’s all going to have to be crammed into a budget resolution and follow-up reconciliation bill, too.

“They’re going to want to use that budget resolution to set up a tax bill, they’re going to want to do other deficit reduction,” said Hazen Marshall, a GOP lobbyist and the Senate Budget Committee’s top aide in 2001 and 2003 when reconciliation bills were used to push former President George W. Bush’s tax cuts through Congress.

“So I would think it’s just going to take some time to get everybody on the same page as to what the budget resolution’s going to look like,” Marshall said.

In 2001, when Republicans set about the relatively simple task of cutting taxes in an era of unprecedented budget surpluses, it took them until Memorial Day to pass the legislation.

What Republicans would confront next year is far more difficult — wrenching cuts to programs popular with voters. A more apt comparison might be the GOP’s budget efforts of 1995, when it took the party until November to complete action on its budget plan.

“It’s not that it’s not doable. It absolutely is doable,” said a senior House GOP budget aide. “It’s just going to take a lot longer than everybody wants it to. And people aren’t anticipating the pain of each step to get to that point.” The aide spoke on condition of anonymity because he wasn’t authorized to speak on the record.

Republicans currently hold 47 Senate seats. If they take control of the Senate, it’s not likely to be by more than 1 to 4 votes, well short of 60. That would put lots of leverage in the hands of Senate GOP moderates like Susan Collins of Maine and Scott Brown of Massachusetts, should he win his difficult re-election bid.

Both Collins and Brown cast votes earlier this year against the House GOP budget plan, authored by Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wis. At the center of Ryan’s plan was controversial overhaul of Medicare that would transform it into a voucher-like program for those who retire in 10 years. Also voting against Ryan’s plan was Rep. Denny Rehberg, R-Mont., who Republicans are counting on to win a Senate seat this fall as a building block to a GOP majority.

Keith Hennessey, a former GOP Senate and White House official, says that if Republicans follow past practice, they’ll try to forge a center-right agreement that includes spending cuts but no tax increases. But he noted that the willingness of some Republicans to embrace tax increases could complicate matters.

“You look at the Republicans and you see that there’s going to be a spectrum on how deep they’re going to be willing to cut various things,” said Hennessey, currently a research fellow at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University. “The question is just how far toward the Ryan plan can you get the moderate Republicans.”

On the other hand, combining the repeal of Obama’s health care law with other GOP priorities like curbing the deficit gives lawmakers who are not part of the leadership plenty of incentive to vote for the package.

“When elections are about certain policies and are defined on that, you’ve got momentum to do those things,” said House GOP Whip Kevin McCarthy of California.

A simple-majority reconciliation bill could certainly cover the health care law’s tax increases — including the penalties used to enforce the individual mandate to buy insurance — and subsidies for insurance premiums.

Republicans, however, could not use the filibuster-proof budget process to repeal provisions in the health care that don’t have a direct impact on the government’s balance sheet. For example, it still would likely take 60 Senate votes to repeal the law’s requirement that insurance companies cover people with pre-existing conditions.

Experts say leaving the insurance reforms intact on their own is economically unsustainable because the ratio of sick to healthy people in the plans would be out of balance.

“If you were to remove everything else in reconciliation and be left with the insurance provisions, you have something that everybody recognizes is unworkable,” said former Congressional Budget Office Director Douglas Holtz-Eakin. “I think if you take enough out, the rest probably has to go.”

Copyright 2012 The Associated Press.

  • limbaugh-16x9.jpg
    Next Story:

    Rush Limbaugh: NAACP is an ‘extremist group’

  • Former Republican Presidential Candidate Herman Cain speaks to guests at the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) at the Donald E. Stephens Convention Center on June 8, 2012 in Rosemont, Illinois. CPAC is being hosted by the American Conservative Union. (Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images)
    Previous Story:

    Herman Cain: The NAACP ‘has lost its relevance’

Filed in: Politics | Related Topics: Affordable Care Act, Barack Obama, Congress, Election 2012, Health Care, Health Care Reform, Mitt Romney, Obamacare, Repeal, Republicans
  • Learn about our User Panel

    Read More
  • New Stories on theGrio

    • Is Jennifer Hudson returning to ‘American Idol’ as a judge? Is Jennifer Hudson returning to ‘American Idol’ as a judge?
    • Charles Ramsey stars in video game Charles Ramsey stars in video game
    • Morgan Freeman: Sleeping during his interview or testing ‘Google Eyelids’? Morgan Freeman: Sleeping during his interview or testing ‘Google Eyelids’?
    • Tavis Smiley marks 10th year on PBS Tavis Smiley marks 10th year on PBS
    • European golf tour CEO apologizes for using term ‘colored’
    • Will Anthony Weiner woo black voters in NYC?
    • Calling all grill masters! Healthy Memorial Day cooking
    • Phil Jackson would pick Bill Russell to start a team with
  • What Your Friends Are Reading

  • More from theGrio

More Stories on theGrio

Top News

Politics

  • Patrick Smith/Getty Images News

    Obama cites new framework for terror war

  • Obama's 1979 prom photo, yearbook note to 'foxy' friend unearthed

  • Are the Obamas too critical of black Americans?

  • First lady makes Forbes' 'Most Powerful Women'

» Read More in Politics

Business

  • An elderly black couple. © poco_bw – Fotolia.com

    Black Americans retiring earlier, with less savings

  • BlackStartup.com seeks to uplift black businesses

  • Payday loans: A debt trap in disguise

  • Tiger Woods makes a comeback on the course, and in video game sales

» Read More in Business

Living

  • A black couple on vacation

    Memorial Day staycation hotspots!

  • Worst foods for high blood pressure

  • Autism Speaks launches new campaign for Latino, black parents

  • Zoe Saldana, Nina Simone and the erasure of black women in film

» Read More in Living

Inspiration

  • Television journalist Robin Roberts poses with her Peabody at the 72nd Annual Peabody Awards at the Waldorf-Astoria on Monday, May 20, 2013 in New York. (Photo by Evan Agostini/Invision/AP)

    Robin Roberts to write memoir about illness

  • Charlotte remembers 1963 desegregation 'eat-in'

  • Tornado survivor saved by teacher

  • Obama speech makes Morehouse grads 'proud'

» Read More in Inspiration

Entertainment

  • In this April 28, 2013 file photo, singer Darius Rucker poses for a portrait backstage on day 3 of the 2013 Stagecoach Music Festival at the Empire Polo Club, in Indio, Calif. Rucker's version of "Wagon Wheel" is the most successful song of his country career. The cut from his third Nashville-recorded album, "True Believers," out on May 21, 2013, has sold nearly 1.2 million copies and sat atop the country charts for three consecutive weeks early this year. (Photo by Dan Steinberg/Invision/AP, File)

    Darius Rucker rides 'Wagon Wheel' to top of charts

  • Janet Jackson officially hits billionaire status

  • Cash Money Records signs Paris Hilton?

  • Comedians pay tribute to 'Bill Cosby: Himself' 30 years later

» Read More in Entertainment

News

  • New Yorkers try to stay cool June 10, 2008 in the Bronx borough of New York City. Temperatures reached into the upper 90's again today during an early heat wave in the city. (Photo by Mario Tama/Getty Images)

    Bronx 'ghetto' tours stop amid outrage

  • Brooklyn man survives Oklahoma tornado

  • Teen arrested for botched science experiment talks about ordeal

  • Chicago Board of Ed votes to close 50 schools

» Read More in News

Main menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
  • Politics
  • Living
  • Video
  • Inspire
  • Health
  • Entertainment
  • News
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise with TheGrio
  • About
©2013 NBCUniversal
Powered by WordPress.com VIP