North Carolina DA won’t press charges for death of Black man hogtied in police custody

Although Marcus Deon Smith, a Black man in police custody, died while placed in a restraining device, the officers involved will not be held accountable

(Adobe Stock Image)


A Greensboro, N.C., prosecutor has chosen not to charge local police for misconduct following the death of Black man who died after being placed in a Ripp Hobble restraining device.

According the Rhino Times, this week, newly retired Guilford County District Attorney Doug Henderson sent a letter to Police Chief Wayne Scott explaining his findings after a probe was done by the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation.

READ MORE: San Jose police mount cameras on officers heads

Scott believes that despite the tragic circumstances surrounding the death of Marcus Deon Smith in September, the officers present acted responsibly and within the law.

“It was concluded that from the overall death investigation and postmortem examination that the cause of death was a sudden cardiopulmonary arrest due in part to the prone restraint, a combination of illicit drugs and alcohol, and hypertensive and atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease,” said Henderson in a letter obtained by the Times on January 4th.

Although the North Carolina medical examiner’s office’s autopsy report ruled 38-year-old Smith’s death a homicide, Henderson still believes there was no misconduct.

READ MORE: Police confront 2 men, 1 white, 1 black: Only 1 is shot

READ MORE: Two Black men, at the center of Memphis mall ‘hoodie arrest,’ prepare for their day in court

“Left for this Office’s determination is whether those actions by the officers provide a basis for a criminal homicide by committing a culpably negligent act,” he elaborated in his memo. “The unequivocal answer is that there is no evidence to substantiate a basis for criminal charges in this matter.”

The Smith family’s attorney, Graham Holt, said his clients are understandably disappointed in the decision.

During a transport to the Hospital, Smith was restrained using the Ripp device, which binds the ankles and includes a strap that is used to attach the ankles to the handcuffs shackling the subject’s hands behind the back.

Henderson maintains that Smith wasn’t taken to the hospital using what is commonly known as a hogtie but did admit that the medical examiner said the device contributed to his death.