Nikole Hannah-Jones refuses to join UNC faculty without tenure, cites discrimination

"Any appointment of Ms. Hannah-Jones without tenure is unacceptable."

Loading the player...

The legal team for Nikole Hannah-Jones has fired off a letter to UNC-Chapel Hill this week noting that she will not begin her position as Knight Chair in Race and Investigative Journalism on July 1, as scheduled, without tenure.

Hannah-Jones, creator of the 1619 Project, does not intend to withdraw her application for tenure — nor has she accepted the university’s offer of a five-year fixed-term contract. 

As previously reported by theGrio, the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill has reneged on a tenured position it offered the Pulitzer-winning journalist amid backlash from conservatives over the 1619 Project. Instead, the university is offering Hannah-Jones a fixed 5-year appointment, as reported by NC Policy Watch.

Previous Knight Chairs at UNC have been hired with tenure.

In this May 21, 2016, file photo, Nikole Hannah-Jones attends the 75th Annual Peabody Awards Ceremony at Cipriani Wall Street in New York. (Photo by Evan Agostini/Invision/AP, File)

One of the loudest opponents to her tenure position, and the most influential warning against the hire, is millionaire mogul Walter Hussman. He donated $25 million to the journalism school named after him. 

Hannah-Jones’s legal team notes in the letter to UNC-Chapel Hill that “political interference and influence from a powerful donor contributed to the Board of Trustees’ failure to consider her tenure application,” they wrote. 

“In light of this information, Ms. Hannah-Jones cannot trust that the University would consider her tenure application in good faith during the period of the fixed-term contract. Such good faith consideration for tenure was understood to be an essential element of the fixed-term contract when Ms. Hannah-Jones agreed to enter into it.

“In light of the information which has come to her attention since that time, she cannot begin employment with the University without the protection and security of tenure.”

Hannah-Jones reportedly intends to move forward with legal action to challenge the UNC Board of Trustees‘ blatant discrimination. 

“The inferior terms of employment offered to Ms. Hannah-Jones in the fixed-term contract resulted from viewpoint discrimination in violation of the freedom of speech and expression, secured by the United States and North Carolina Constitution; race and sex discrimination and retaliation in violation of federal and North Carolina state law; unlawful political influence in violation of North Carolina state law; and other unlawful grounds,” her legal team wrote.

“Under these circumstances, any appointment of Ms. Hannah-Jones without tenure is unacceptable,” the letter stated.  

Nikole Hannah-Jones thegrio.com
Nikole Hannah-Jones attends the “Neutral Ground” premiere during the 2021 Tribeca Festival at Pier 76 on June 19, 2021 in New York City. (Photo by Monica Schipper/Getty Images for Tribeca Festival)

Students, faculty, and alumni have condemned the board’s failure to hold a tenure vote lead, TheWrap reports, noting that “The university has reportedly lost several high-profile Black candidates, faculty and staff members amid the controversy,” the outlet reported.

Several Black students have allegedly refused to come back to school this fall amid the scandal. According to the Carolina Black Caucus, a majority of the board members are considering leaving the university.

“At the end of the month the tenure of some board members is up and some new ones are going to come onto the board,” one trustee said. “I think they just want to let that happen, so they don’t have to deal with it. But I think that strategy could cost the school a good new faculty member, it is costing us faculty members right now who are leaving over all of this, and it is damaging the reputation of the school.”

Meanwhile, UNC-Chapel Hill Chancellor Kevin Guskiewicz has repeatedly said Hannah-Jones will begin her position on July 1.

“But this letter makes it clear she’s not going to begin the job that way and give them what they want on that,” the trustee said. “They want her to take the job under different and lesser conditions than her white predecessors did, and I think continuing to push that is dangerous for the university’s reputation and it’s a bad legal strategy.

“If we don’t deal with this sooner rather than later we are going to be fighting a legal fight over it while we have Black students and faculty leaving the university in large numbers, which we are already seeing. How do we think we are going to recruit top students and faculty under these conditions?”

In an open letter to the Carolina community, Mimi Chapman, chair of the school’s faculty, describes the national attention on Hannah-Jones’s tenure as a “reputational threat to our University grows by the day and we remain in the headlines for all the wrong reasons.”

This story contains additional reporting from Sytonia Reid.

Have you subscribed to theGrio’s “Dear Culture” podcast? Download our newest episodes now!
TheGrio is now on Apple TV, Amazon Fire and Roku. Download theGrio.com today!

Loading the player...